c 1836-1837 Historic Hyco House - 6,500+/- SF on 3 levels Mathews, VA

Property Location MAP

10941 Buckley Hall Rd
Mathews, VA 23109

Property #: FX4664

Preview Times

Sunday 6/6 @ 4 :00PM - 6 :00PM ET
Monday 6/14 @ 4 :00PM - 6 :00PM ET

Contact Agent

Linda Terry
Tranzon Fox



  • Subscription/Login Required
  • Confidentiality Agreement Required

c 1836-1837 Historic Hyco House - 6,500+/- SF on 3 levels
  • 11 Bedrooms, 6 Baths
  • Most recently an event venue, home and workshop of renowned fine furniture craftsman, Sam Forrest
  • Served as home/medical office for Dr. James William Dorsey Haynes 1940's-1950's
  • Suited for Bed & Breakfast, Event Venue, AirBNB

Owner financing is available

+/- 6,500 SF per tax record

First and second floors +/- 3,736
2 bedrooms, 1 bath first level
4 bedrooms, 2 baths second floor
3 bedrooms, 1 bath attic

Basement +/-2,764
2 bedrooms, 2 baths
Living room
Second kitchen
Unfinished storage areas

Finished attic

1.245+/- acres
Brick foundation, vinyl siding, slate and metal roof
Open porches, deck area
Gazebo, shed and woodworking shop with wood stove

Welcome to the historic Hyco House! A grand 1830's Greek Revival home is within walking distance of shops, restaurants, post office and banks in Mathews. The closest marina is Morningstar, near the Coast Guard station. This home was most recently used as a shop, art gallery, affordable hostel stop over for cyclists, more upscale bed and breakfast rooms (fix your own in the kitchen, or walk across to Hardees!), event venue (ever heard of Hosting a Murder?), and woodworking studio. The Certificate of Occupancy was for a lodge.

Just as famous as this unique house, was it's most recent owner, artisan woodworker, Sam Forrest. His website aptly reads:
"One of a kind pieces
from the heart, mind, & hand of a
one of a kind man."

Sam travelled the world, but had roots in Mathews, so he eventually came home. When he purchased the Hyco House in 2018, he renamed it Haiku House, and built a substantial woodworking shop with concrete floor and woodstove, where Sam continued to turn out his beautiful, original furniture designs.

While the house is livable as is, a new owner may choose to return it to original splendor by releasing the random width pine flooring from its vinyl covering and carpeting, upgrading the main kitchen, baths, and adding luxury touches here and there. High ceilings, tall windows and several old coal fireplaces are punctuated throughout with bullseye molding. A heat pump was added to serve the basement living area and main level; second floor rooms have split wall or window units, and there are window unit AC's in the attic rooms.

The main living level has a lovely parlor with tall window-lined music conservatory at the end, formal dining room with fireplace, and doors that open out onto the generous deck; kitchen with rear stairs to a bedroom and bath (former servants' quarters). Two bedrooms and a full bath with shower are on this floor as well. Upstairs are 3 generous bedrooms, one is a suite with bow window and fireplace, full bath. Two additional bedrooms share a hall bath with tub and shower.

The attic hosts 3 cozy bedrooms with window A/C units (lower ceilings) and a hall bath with shower.

Sam chose to live in the basement, where you'll find 2 bedrooms, 2 baths, a second full kitchen and living room that he used to practice yoga. The larger bedroom has an attached bath and separate outside entrance.

The Mathews County Historical Society had the house surveyed by architectural historian Dr. Carl Lounsbury for the Society's book Historic Homes and Properties of Mathews County, Virginia, Volume 4. Dr. Lounsbury has worked for the Colonial Williamsburg Foundation, teaches architectural history at the College of William and Mary, and is highly regarded in the architectural community.

Parcel ID#: 26-A2-17-1
2020 Tax Assessment: $447,300
2020 Annual Taxes: $2,885
Zoning: Res - CO approved for use as a "lodge"

Please be sure to download the Property Information Package by clicking on the words above under “DOCUMENTS.” By downloading this package you will alert Tranzon to your interest in this property and you will receive emails with any updates on this auction. The package contains information needed to participate in bidding at auction.


The following summary of Terms & Conditions of Auction Sale is only intended to provide you a brief outline. For a complete copy, either download the Property Information Package, if available, or contact Linda Terry

Linda Terry: Tranzon Fox


All bidders must agree to all of the Terms & Conditions of Auction Sale prior to bidding at any Tranzon auction. Listings may be withdrawn or modified without notice at anytime.

For general information on the auction process, please review the Frequently Asked Questions.

Print Terms and Conditions

  • Buyer's Premium: 10% Buyers Premium based on the high bid.
  • Closing: 45-Day closing, sold in As-Is condition, no contingencies.
  • Deposit Amount: 10% deposit due within 2 business days of being notified that you are the successful high bidder.
  • Broker Co-op: 2% of the high bid will be paid to a properly registered broker at settlement.
  • Agency Disclosure: The member company acting as auctioneer/agent is an agent for the seller only.
  • Disclaimer: Information contained herein is believed to be correct to the best of auctioneer/agent's knowledge but is subject to inspection and verification by all parties relying on it. Sellers, their representatives and auctioneer/agent shall not be liable for inaccuracies, errors, or omissions. All square footage and other dimensions are approximate. This offering is subject to prior sale and may be withdrawn, modified or cancelled at any time without notice.

Online Bidding Instructions:

See terms and conditions in the property information package.

Have a Property To Sell? Request a FREE Property Consultation